At a Glance
Most remittances can and will be posted by Athelas automatically. However, payers occasionally send malformed, duplicate, or conflicting data in their remittances. Athelas will flag these cases for manual review, either by our operations team or your practice’s staff.
This guide contains common scenarios in which remittances get flagged for manual review and examples of how to handle them.
🚧 Common Signs that a Remittance Needs Manual Review
- It is stuck in the Payer 2 or 3 stage with no posted payment
- It is stuck in the Finalization Pending stage
- Sometimes these claims will look balanced, but there are still remits in manual review — most likely duplicates
- It has a negative balance
- This often occurs when…
- The payer sends a second remittance without rescinding the first
- There are duplicate remittances
- A payer autoforwarded a claim to the next payer without informing Athelas
- There are incorrect payer clawbacks
- Sometimes, payers retroactively deny a claim and then try to rescind the wrong amount
Common Scenarios
👯♀️ Duplicate (or Nearly Duplicate) Remittances
These are some of the most common cases of remits requiring manual review.
How to Handle Duplicate Remittances
The short version:
- If the currently-posted (first) remittance is accurate, simply archive the unposted (second) remittance.
- If the second remittance is accurate, negate the first and post the second.
Walkthrough
🥇Situation 1: The currently-posted remittance is accurate (or they’re exact duplicates)
- Visit the Posting Tool page and find the encounter of interest. Click its arrow icon to see procedures listed by DoS.
- Find the procedure remit you want to review, then click
Post/Adjust
.
- The remittance for manual review will be in the Unposted Remittances list.
- If you hover your cursor over the information icon, a tooltip will explain why this remit is unposted. In this example, we can see that the remit will create a negative balance (indicative of overpayment) if it is posted.
- Looking at the Posted Payments list, it is clear that a duplicate remittance was already posted for this DoS.
- In this case, it is safe to archive the unposted remittance by clicking the orange box icon in the Actions column.
🥈Situation 2: The unposted remittance is accurate
- Visit the Posting Tool page and find the encounter of interest. Click its arrow icon to see procedures listed by DoS. Find the procedure remit you want to review, then click
Post/Adjust
.
- The remittance for manual review will be in the Unposted Remittances list.
- If you hover your cursor over the information icon, a tooltip will explain why this remit is unposted. In this example, we can see that the remit will create a negative balance (indicative of overpayment) if it is posted.
- Looking at the Posted Payments list, it is clear that a duplicate remittance was already posted for this DoS.
- Now, rather than archiving the unposted remittance as shown in the previous situation, we’ll negate the first and post the second.
Click the three dots corresponding to the first remittance under the Actions column. Choose
Negate
.
- Write a note explaining the negation, then click
Confirm
.
The Posting Tool page automatically shows you previews of the effects of all changes — negations, posts, edits — that you wish to make. No changes will take effect until you click Confirm Posting
in the bottom right corner of the page.
- Your negation will be in the Posted Payments list, highlighted red, indicating that it is currently an unconfirmed preview. You can see how confirming this negation will affect the encounter’s financial information, written in blue text in the Procedure Summary.
- You can always click the Undo arrow in the Actions column to cancel a previewed change.
- We’ll preview both the negation AND the new posting together for this walkthrough. Click the green checkmark ✅ next to the unposted remittance. This will bump it up into the Posted Payments list in preview mode, highlighted blue, underneath the negation preview you just made.
- Changes to the balance will update in the Procedure Summary in blue text.
- In this case, as they are duplicate remittances, negating one and posting the other yields no change, but we’ll do it anyway to show the process.
- Once everything looks as expected, click
Confirm Posting
.
If you need to make further adjustments to balance the encounter, this guide has information on making a custom adjustment. It can be found near the bottom of the Posting/Adjustments Tool section.
Done! Time for coffee. ☕
🦞 Second Decision Without a Clawback (Leading Cause of Negative Balances)
When a payer sends a second decision on an encounter without rescinding the first, a telltale negative balance appears (indicating overpayment).
How to Handle a Second Decision Without a Clawback
The short version:
- Negate the first remittance
- Post the second remittance
Follow the Duplicate Remittances procedure for 🥈Situation 2, in which the second remittance is accurate. Please refer to those instructions (above) for a walkthrough.
🥷 Secondary or Tertiary Payer Stage Disguised as Primary
A sneaky and rare situation that’s harder to detect, but can be solved.
For cases like this, a few telltale signs are:
- The payer stage doesn’t make sense in context
- We see the same payer name across remittances from all payers
- Mismatched payer name and index
- For example, remittances from BCBS show up as Payer 1, even though they should display as Payer 2
- Two payers for a patient are the same insurance
- This can happen, for example, if we have a patient’s primary insurance listed as secondary, and then that insurance sends back a remittance as the primary payer.
How to Fix These Cases
The short version:
- Change the payer on the remittance from Claim Details, which will move all amounts to the appropriate columns
OR
- Change the payer on the remittance in the Posting Tool
- Move all adjustments (not Copay, Coinsurance, or Deductible) to the ‘Denied’ column
- From Claim Details
- Open an encounter, then click the expansion arrow on a procedure to see its payment ledger. Finally, click the dropdown menu in the ‘Payer’ column to change the payer.
- Refresh the page, double check that everything looks correct now, and make further changes as needed. If necessary, use the Posting Tool method described below instead.
- With the Posting Tool
- Open the claim in question and click the green checkmark on the unposted remittance to preview it. It will bump up to the Posted Payments section, highlighted blue to indicate that it is a preview.
- Scroll to the right to find the ‘Denied’ column. Click the
-
to edit, and add all adjustments to this column. - If you need to change the payer, click the payer in the ‘Ins. Priority’ column on the preview and select the correct priority (Primary, Secondary, or Tertiary).
- Click
Confirm Posting
.
You can change the payer and adjust CARCs with the Posting Tool (check out this guide to learn how to use the Posting Tool).
Done!
👽 Strange Adjustments or Mismatched Clawback
Sometimes, previous adjustments or clawbacks simply don’t make sense.
How to Fix Them
The short version:
- Make a custom adjustment to correct errors
OR…
- Negate the bad clawback, and negate the posted payment item to which it applied
1. Make a Custom Adjustment
Check out this guide to learn how to make a custom adjustment.
2. Negate Both Items
- From the Posting Tool page, find the encounter of interest and click the arrow to see all of its procedures. Locate the procedure to be modified and click
Post/Adjust
.
- For both the bad clawback and the payment item to which it applied, click the three dots under the Action column and choose
Negate
.
- You’ll now see previews of both negations in the Posted Payments list, highlighted red.
- The Posting Tool automatically shows previews of all potential changes. These changes will not take effect until you click
Confirm Posting
. - Check the blue preview text in the Procedure Summary section to see how your negations will affect the financial information of the encounter.
- You can always cancel a proposed change by clicking the Undo arrow under the Actions menu.
- If everything looks as expected, click the
Confirm Posting
button in the bottom right corner of the page.
Done!
⏳ Payment Received After Write-Off
Given the unpredictable timing of insurance payouts, it’s not unusual for payments to come through after the charge they cover has already been written off. Fortunately, there are solutions to this problem.
Case Study
❓The Problem
- The payer initially denied a claim due to a non-qualifying diagnosis.
- The practice wrote off the charge.
- The payer later paid a portion of the claim. The claim’s status was listed as ‘Non-workable,’ requiring a review of the payment history and balance adjustment.
✅ The Solution
The short version:
- Negate the write off
- Post the payout
- Locate the Encounter in Question
- From the Posting Tool page, open the
Patient
filter and use it to find the patient.
There are many ways to do this in Insights. Click this toggle for a walkthrough of the most efficient method for this particular case study.
ii. Find the encounter of interest and click the arrow icon to see procedure and charge details. Find the correct procedure and click Post/Adjust
.
- Review Payment History.
- Confirm that the payer has indeed issued a partial payment, despite the initial denial.
💡 Open a separate tab so that you can view the Posting Tool and the Claim Timeline simultaneously. Click this toggle to learn how to locate the Claim Timeline.
Copy the Encounter ID from the Posting Tool page you’re currently on.
Press Cmd + K
if you’re on a Mac, or Ctrl + K
if you’re on a PC, and a universal search modal will appear. Paste the Encounter ID into the search bar. Select the option to see that encounter on the Claim Details page.
Once viewing the correct claim, click into the Timelines tab, which will default to the Claim Timeline. Scroll down until you reach the date of interest.
✅ Now you can compare the Posting Tool and the Encounter Timeline side by side.
- Check Payment History for Payment Reversal
- Look through the encounter’s claim timeline to verify that the payment was not rescinded, ensuring that the amount is still valid in the system.
- Negate the Incorrect Write-Off
- Under the ‘Actions’ column in the Posting Tool tab, click the three dots corresponding to the incorrect write-off. Choose
Negate
. - In the popup, fill in the reason for the negation. Click
Confirm
. - You can now see a preview of your negation, highlighted red, in the Posted Payments list.
- 💡The negation won’t take effect until you click
Confirm Posting
in the bottom right corner of the page. For this walkthrough, we’ll wait until after the next step to confirm posting.
- Adjust the Balance
- To post only your negation and wait for automatic remittance posting:
- Double check the preview result
- Make any changes if necessary
- Click
Confirm Posting
The new remittance will be displayed in the Unposted Remittances list.
All remittances in the Unposted Remittances list with PENDING Posting Status post automatically every six hours, if no errors or negative balances will appear as a result.
However, any remittances in the Unposted Remittances list with ’Manual Review Required’ status will need to be manually posted.
For this walkthrough, since the unposted remittances are in ‘Manual Review Required’ status, we will need to combine the negation with manual posting.
With the Posting Tool’s (automatic and required) preview function, the Procedure Summary at the top of the page will update to show your potential changes in blue text.
The screenshot below shows how the Adjustments and Balance would be affected if the negation is confirmed.
✍️ How to Preview and Post the Remittance Manually
Click the green checkmark next to the unposted remittance. This will bump it up into the Posted Payments list in preview mode and highlight it in blue, underneath the negation you just made.
In the Procedure Summary, you can now see how both the negation and the new remittance would affect the Adjustments and Balance, should they be confirmed.
Ideally, the preview of the negation and the new remittance will create a new balance of $0, or otherwise yield the result you expect.
You can always click the Undo arrow next to any preview item to remove it from consideration.
Once the preview matches your expectations, click Confirm Posting
.
The changes you made can now be found in the Posted Payments list.
If you need to make a custom adjustment and would like a walkthrough, see the end of the Posting/Adjustments Tool (with Preview Mode) section of this guide.
Done!
🚙 Autoforwarding
Sometimes, the primary payer will automatically forward a claim to secondary without informing Athelas. When secondary pays, Insights will display a primary PR of $0 along with a payout from secondary, resulting in a negative balance.
How to Resolve Negative Balances from Autoforwarded Claims
The short version:
- Post the secondary remittance
- Make a negative, custom adjustment in the ‘Other Adjustments’ column that balances the paid amount
Use the Posting Tool to post the secondary remittance (to learn how to use the Posting Tool, see this guide).
It will appear as a preview in the Posted Payment section, highlighted blue.
Create a custom adjustment on the primary remittance. It will appear as a preview in the Posted Payments section, highlighted purple.
In the ‘Other Adjustments’ column, write in a negative adjustment that balances the paid amount, with a note explaining the negative adjustment. This prevents the “overpayment” from creating a negative balance that would leave the encounter in “Payer 2 Stage”. Double check that posting both the new remittance and the custom adjustment result in a balance of $0 in the preview. Then, click Confirm Posting
.
Done! ☕
Further Assistance
📢 We’re here to help! Please contact your account manager if you would like some hands-on assistance.